Moondark for March: Messier by the Numbers

Each March, star gazers emerge from winter hibernation for the Messier marathon, a one-night, all-you-can-see tour of the catalog first compiled over 200 years ago as a list of objects to avoid while comet hunting. It’s all about the numbers, how many you can see: 100, 108, 109 109 is the maximum number visible at Tuckahoe: all but M30 even 110 To get 110,  the 'missing' M102 is taken to be NGC 5866, but numbers are just the metric. It’s fundamentally about your deep-sky observing skills, your star-hopping ability, and basically how well you know the sky. And while a lone observer can undertake it, most often this is an astro-social affair, which make the competition to see the most objects all the more keen. As a warm-up, check your own knowledge of the Messier objects with this quiz. Move your mouse over the Messier monogram button Mouseover the monogram graphic and reveal the answers... to reveal the answer.

How many did Messier actually observe himself? 100 in the original catalog of 103, plus 4 in observations recorded elsewhere How many are listings of objects discovered by contemporary colleagues? Six are attributed to Méchain: M101 - 103 and M105 - 107 How many are just oddballs, mistakes or duplicates? M24 is the Sagittarius Star Cloud, and M40 is an unremarkable double star in UMaThere are fascinating detective stories for: M47, M48, M73, M91 and especially M102--see Machholz's book

Next, these questions pertain to the position of the Messier objects on the celestial sphere. Which one is the northernmost? M81 and M82, at +69° 04 and +69° 41 in UMa Southernmost? M7 at -34° 49', but M6, M69 and M70 are close, within 2° Which are the most “west” and most “east” in terms of right ascension? M31, M32 and M110 are at 0 h 40 m, while M52 is at 23h 24 m, preceded by M15, M30 and M39 Why are there none south of declination -35°? Messier observed from Paris at nearly 50° N latitude: objects below -40° would be below his horizon Which two form the closest pair? M42 and M43 are but 0.13° apart; M65 and M66 are 0.34°, and M59 and M60 are 0.43° apart Which one is the most isolated? Surprisingly, The Pleiades, M45--it's 23° to M34, almost 25° to M38 and M1! Where is the densest concentration? As you might guess: in the Realm of Galaxies in Virgo there are 17 within 10° of M59, M60, M90 and M91 How many can be seen in one eyepiece at one time? For a 1° eyepiece: three fields hold 3 galaxies: M32, M32, M110 in And, M89, M90, M58 in Vir; and M96, M95, M105 in LeoIn a 5° bino/finder field: there are 14 M-objects centered on M87 and on M88

These answers are specific to observing the Messier objects from a particular location, here, Tuckahoe State Park located at 38° 59' N and 75° 56' W. How many are always above the horizon, termed circumpolar? 11: M40, M52, M76, M81, M82, M97, M101, M102, M103, M108, and M109 Which are the first to tackle in the evening? M74, M33, M110, all low surface brightness galaxies Which are the last in the morning? M72, M73 and M2; M30 is all but impossible in the morning twilight Why is globular cluster M30 so challenging? M30 rises 13 min after astro-twilight begins and is only 3° up at nautical twilight When are the most Messier objects overhead at once? 88 of 110 (that's 4 of 5!) are above the horizon at 15:45 h LST or 03:25 EST on 29 March at Tuckahoe When are there the fewest? Only 63 Messier objects are above Tuckahoe's horizon around 10 h LST or 22:00 EST on 28 March

Finally, these can only be answered by you: Have you seen them all? Yes, but it's been a long time. I gotta get out more... What’s your favorite Messier object? M57, the Ring Nebula, without a doubt Your least favorite or maybe the one you find hardest to see? M76 the Little Dumbbell--just can't get excited by this one Which is the most rewarding to observe? It's hard to beat the Great Orion Nebula, M42--it definitely deserves the term!

Answers, solid advice, suggested dates and observing sequences can be found in Don Machholz’s The Observing Guide to the Messier Marathon, published by Cambridge University Press (2002). There are many other marathons to enjoy once you’ve tackled the Messier list. Another great printed resource is Howard Pennington’s The Year-Round Messier Marathon Field Guide (Willmann-Bell, 1997). While late March is optimal for most locations (for example, considering the moon's phase 26-27 day-old waning crescent; New Moon follows on Tuesday, 1 April 2003, 2003's prime weekend is Friday-Saturday 28-29 March Astro-twilight ends at 19:54, begins at 04:23 at Tuckahoe), many Messier objects are visible at any time of the year. For example, over 100 are visible from mid-northern latitudes in mid-October, when the sky clarity and nighttime low temperatures are often more favorable. In any event, don't forget coffee and late-night snacks!

Available on the web, two programs, both by Bev M. Ewan-Smith, are available to help in running your Messier Marathon. Given a date, the Messier Object Visibility Program will return a table of which objects The maximum is 109 since M102 is considered a duplicate of M101 are visible from your location (use N 39 and W 76 for Tuckahoe). More tables and graphs are generated by the MESSMARA or COAA Messier Marathon Windows Application (scroll to the bottom of this link).  Also check the moon phase, deep night calendars and clear sky clock to plan your marathon. Good luck this month and clear skies!

Amazingly, all these trivial-sounding "factoids" reveal the structure of the universe. The distribution of Messier objects across the sky is certainly not random. Diffuse nebulae and open cluster trace the Milky Way’s spiral arms, while globular clusters swarm around the galactic center. Stepping up, the large, bright spirals like M31 and M33 are our neighbors, and the swaths of mixed elliptical and spiral galaxies in Virgo, Leo and Ursa Major hint at the most immense structures known. This is truly awesome! Seeing all this from your backyard, much less in one night, is perhaps the most remarkable fact of all.

Sorry--no CCD images this month--it’s impossible to choose my favorite among the Messier objects! The monogram background and button were scanned from that printed in Kenneth Glyn Jones’s Messier’s Nebulae and Star Clusters, 2nd edition (1991, Cambridge). I’d love to hear your answers to these questions or especially if I’ve fouled-up an answer or two. Moondark is written by Doug Miller and published on the web and in the Delmarva Star Gazers'Star Gazer News. This document was last revised on 23 February '03. All text and images copyright © 2003 Douglas C. Miller, All Rights Reserved. This material may not be reproduced in any form without prior permission.